Why makes 3rd party controller layout the way it is, beside demand?

Not a technical question but an opinion.

Why makes the Xbox controller layout more popular than the DS4 counterpart?

(Gulikit pro 2, 8bitdo ultimate blutooth, Gamesir T4, Razer Wolverine,...)

What kind of games do gamers play? That need the left stick to be inline with the right buttons? i can only think of these genre (fighting, racing, 2d platformer, sports)

With playstation layout theres FPS, ARPG, 3d platformer, RPG, action adventure, fps puzzle and alot more that needed simultaneous stick movement

So please humor me, i cant think of any answer for this query