The 2013 revamp of the desktop Mac series known as the Mac Pro.

Preguntas 46 Ver todo

Mac Pro Late 2013: Anything that can be done about coil whine?

Hey guys,

as you are the experts in the field — my Mac Pro exhibits some audible coil whining. I've tried unplugging all kinds of devices and ran the device through another power outlet. I've disabled Bluetooth and WiFi to change power consumption. I've changed the fan speed with iStat menus and tried putting some strain on the GPU and CPU with benchmarks. The noise stays the same: http://cl.ly/3c032O0R3v2a

Any ideas or would you say the noise is within spec? Apple would exchange the nMP for a new one but they are not sure if that would fix the issue...

Contesta esta pregunta Yo también tengo este problema

Es esta una buena pregunta?

Calificación 4
Agregar un comentario

4 Respuestas

Respuesta Más Útil

If you purchased it in the USA from Apple (direct not a box store) you have 14 days to take it back for a different one. If passed that date it should be warranted for one year. Were I you I would be having discussions with Apple Support, not planning on a DIY "fix" for a box that spend and new.

If this answer is acceptable please remember to return and mark it.

Fue útil esta respuesta?

Calificación 1

Comentarios:

What do you think I'm doing. Not really helpful. I'm interested in a tech perspective, not a CRM one.

por

Agregar un comentario

Not quite a solution but I have noticed that if I twist the case when it starts that it will stop. Basically the case can move maybe a quarter mm and this seems to stop it for a while. I almost wonder if the thing is resonating with the case or something?

This does not fix it but it does stop it for a while.

When I twist it I also am pressing on the interior so that could also be part of this "fix"

Oh I took mine in during the first week and they replaced the power something. Didn't fix it. The problem was that their shop was too noisy to hear it.

Update (10/20/2014)

I discovered that this whine is mostly related to having an Ethernet cable plugged in. Then I noticed that the whine is the sound of data flowing through that port. Send a huge file and it is loud and continuous. Stop all connections(including others on that network) and it is just an intermittent buzz of the network chattering.

I took my machine into the apple store shortly after buying it. I don't think they actually heard the whine and I hadn't yet connected it to having an ethernet cable plugged in. They replaced the power board or some such. Didn't fix anything. Still whine all this time later.

Fue útil esta respuesta?

Calificación 1

Comentarios:

We had one system that had a noise problem it was noise on the Ethernet network which was crossing over (poor grounding). First get a good surge suppressor which has some noise filtering or get a UPS (best). You may need more than one unit (system and network hub/switch).

Also check your buildings wiring. Make sure the ground pin is wired at the outlets and the ground lines in the breaker panel are properly bonded to the ground frame (all of the breaker circuits). Lastly, make sure the grounding line from the breaker panel to the grounding point is in good shape and the grounding rod or pipe connection is not corroded.

If that doesn't fix it you may have a bad logic board. In this case the power noise filtering maybe failing.

por

Agregar un comentario

Hi Sascha!

I remember having had the same problem. When transferring a lot of data via Ethernet or WiFi, it started whining and maybe even „crackling“. Unfortunately I haven't found a solution for this problem.

It's always very frustrating to have coil whine or similar noise issues. At the Genius Bar, it's very often so loud that nobody will be able to hear the whining of the computer.

Since your post is a few years old now, I am quite curious if you found any solution? My solution was to sell the Mac Pro and wait for the next generation (with naive and high hopes).

A thing that just came to my mind: Have you tried to disable the internal ethernet and wifi interface and use a ethernet-to-usb or 3rd party wifi usb adapter? I'd like to know if this would change anything.

Best regards,

Ben

Fue útil esta respuesta?

Calificación 0
Agregar un comentario

This solved my problem, only took less than 1 minute

The first thing you should try is reset the SMC . All you have to do is unplug the computer from the power source ( back of the computer power cord) wait 15 to 25 seconds just in case you count to fast.Then Plug it back in and RESTART the computer the fan should reset back to normal. If this trick does not work then the fan is probably dirty and needs to be cleaned or it may need to be replaced. ( Always Try the simple things first ) like going to ifixit.com and ask a question.

Fue útil esta respuesta?

Calificación 0

Comentarios:

SMC reset didn't solve anything for me. Also, the fan suggestion doesn't help either, since this isn't about fan noise ...

por

@bolandross - Then the only hope here is to replace the power supply.

por

In my case Apple replaced power supply, fan and logic board. Nothing help's. I have well done electricity in my house where tension is always on same constant level. Apple should do repair program for coil whine but they didn't really know whats going wrong on it - what should they change if there is something to change.

por

I would get a UPS it solved our Mac Pro whine.

por

Mine not. I allready have UPS.

por

Mostrar 1 comentario más

Agregar un comentario

Añadir tu respuesta

Sascha estará eternamente agradecido.
Ver Estadísticas:

Ultimas 24 Horas: 2

Últimos 7 Días: 11

Últimos 30 Días: 29

Todo El Tiempo: 1,757